Treasure Hunt Database (THDB)

Graphic of a treasure chest with the words Treasure Hunt Database.
Login
Cover art for Conundrum: The Cadbury’s Creme Egg Mystery

Conundrum
The Cadbury’s Creme Egg Mystery

STATUS: SOLVED

Conundrum was a widely publicized hunt book featuring 12 paintings with corresponding verses, each based on a different region of the British Isles. Each painting/verse spread contained clues leading to a golden egg.


As an effort to promote their creme eggs, which have their peaks sales between January and Easter, Cadbury's released this hunt in January of 1984. Initially, to obtain a copy of the book, one had to purchase twelve Cadbury's creme eggs and mail in the wrappers to get your softcover copy of the book. The hunt was also available in hardcover at bookstores.

For the burial of all the eggs, creator Don Shaw was accompanied by military man Ranulph “Ran” Fiennes. 

According to Evening Sentinel newspaper of Stoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire, England, the sixth egg to be found was The Refuge (Staffordshire), and the 5 eggs found earlier were in Northumberland (actually in County Durham, The Burning Hand), Yorkshire (“W & B”), Dorset (Cuckoo, Cuckoo), Surrey (A Child’s Dream), and Warwickshire (The Prize). An article from Scunthorpe Evening Telegraph on Mar 30, 1984, states seven have been found so far.

Due to many reports of people digging up private property, National Trust land, and other important historical sites, Cadbury dug up the final three caskets and converted to a mail-in submission process. On April 4, 1984, a large ad ran in several national papers announcing the change and new rules, the final three eggs/spreads to be found were Island Mystery, Conundrum, and A Giant's Place. 

Up for Auction

As early as March 1985, eggs were up for Auction. A brief mention is made in Retford, Gainsborough and Worksop Times (March 8, 1985) that a auction for an egg “found on the Shropshire border with Wales” was expected to sell for £4,000 to £6,000. This is believed to be the egg for A Giant’s Place, though it was found fully in Wales, not on the border.

Jumping ahead 34 years, in June of 2017, Bateman’s Auctioneers & Valuers announced that in an upcoming auction a previously unknown 13th egg would be sold. Apparently Cadbury's offered this larger egg in a prize drawing only open to egg-selling retailers, not the public. Scott Gardner of The Armchair Treasure Hunt Club won it via phone during the July 1, 2017 auction for £17,200. He lovingly calls it “Humpty.” Three years later, the 13th egg sold for £31,000. Surprisingly one of the smaller 12 eggs sold for even more. The Cuckoo, Cuckoo egg sold for an astonishing £123,50 in August 2026

Open envelope
Envelope flap
Click to reveal solution

Solution

An account of Clive Pinder finding the Cuckoo, Cuckoo egg was posted in the Quest4Treasure forums.

The content of the scroll in Clive Pinder’s find:

Congratulations

Your search is over. You have won.
We hope that is has all been fun.
There now remains one more small task.
To get your egg, just phone and ask.

To establish ownership of the Cuckoo, Cuckoo egg,
simply telephone this number during office hours:
01-637 0322

You will be asked for a code phrase and you
must reply with this phrase:
“WHAT IF OLD BIRD CAN’T FLY?”

This will prove that you are in fact the
finder of this scroll.

This is your Certificate of Ownership
of the Cuckoo, Cuckoo egg.
Make sure that your keep it safe.